Isaiah Mustafa Returns For a New Old Spice Commercial 2.29K Leah Beckmann 01/26/11 02:05PM Filed to: Old Spice Old Spice Isaiah Mustafa Commercial TV Video Like the "mighty sequoia's of the Redwood forest," the Old Spice Guy, Isaiah Mustafa, is back in another awesome commercial. Yes, we remember those "striking brown eyes," and we're glad they're back.