Since Making a Murderer debuted late last year on Netflix, the internet has been overrun with amateur sleuths looking for evidence presented in Avery’s trial that the show suspiciously overlooked. Investigation Discovery’s Steven Avery: Innocent or Guilty, which premieres tomorrow at 9 pm, features a clip of Murderer co-director Laura Ricciardi explaining, “It would have been impossible for us to include all of the evidence that the state submitted. We chose all of what the state itself was claiming to be its most compelling evidence. We feel that we did a very thorough, a very accurate, and fair job.”

Calumet County prosecutor Ken Kratz got the Making a Murderer conviction but he still wanted more, according to a smarmy letter he sent last year informing Steven Avery he’d be “willing” to write a book about the trial, if Avery would just confess to him, and only him.