Do you remember Comedy Central's Night of Too Many Stars? B.J. Novak was answering phones alongside Tom Hanks and George Clooney, and callers weren't necessarily happy to find out they were talking to "The Temp" from The Office. Also: Smurfs!

Remember when Captain Sully successfully landed a plane on the Hudson? How about the YouTube sensation Chocolate Rain? Stephen Colbert and Steve Carell wrote the hit "Everybody's Talkin' Bout Sully" years ago, but only got around to performing it now.

As a part of the Night of Too Many Stars, Tracy Morgan and Chris Rock donned pale-colored turtlenecks and performed as Simon and Garfunkel. That is, until the real Paul Simon came onto the stage with some musical suggestions.

During the Night of Too Many Stars, Tina Fey graciously offered up her personal calendar. Inside, she goes through a year of photo spreads—which include her shirtless, with washboard abs, as Justin Bieber, and as twins of herself.