Martha's Vineyard Nabs the Thief Who's Been Robbing Its Cute Sweater Boutiques: A Wealthy Socialite Caity Weaver · 09/07/12 05:53PM A very déclassé thing happened to Joelle O'Reilly-Hyland as she and her family were about to board the 9:30 pm ferry to Woods Hole from Martha's Vineyard. She was arrested for stealing cute outfits.